Skip to main content
The Axeman of New Orleans
CASE FILEHistoricalUncertain

The Axeman of New Orleans

1918
New Orleans, Louisiana, USA
4Evidence Items
5Theories
4Witnesses
StatusDeclassified

Case Summary

Mysterious serial killer terrorized New Orleans from 1918-1919, targeting Italian grocers with axes. Left cryptic letters claiming to be a demon who spared jazz lovers.

Official Narrative

Between 1918-1919, New Orleans Police Department investigated a series of axe attacks targeting Italian-American families, primarily grocers. The perpetrator gained entry by chiseling door panels, used victims' own axes, and left no evidence of robbery. Twelve attacks resulted in six deaths. Investigation included analysis of the March 1919 letter published in Times-Picayune newspaper. Case remains officially unsolved with no arrests made. Files transferred to NOPD Cold Case Unit.

Evidence Archive

4 items
The Hell Demon Letter to New Orleans Newspapers
The Hell Demon Letter to New Orleans Newspapers
Police Crime Scene Reports and Survivor Testimonies
Contemporary Newspaper Coverage and Public Response
Contemporary Newspaper Coverage and Public Response

Theories & Analysis

5 theories
1

Anti-Italian Hate Crime Spree

Source: Hair, William Ivy. The Axeman of New Orleans
2

Mafia Protection Racket Gone Wrong

Source: Davis, John H. Mafia Kingfish
3

Multiple Copycat Killers

Source: Geary, Rick. The Axe-Man of New Orleans
4

Joseph Mumfre Theory

Source: Tallant, Robert. Ready to Hang
5

Psychological Profile: The Demon Persona

Source: Newton, Michael. The Encyclopedia of Serial Killers

Eyewitness Accounts

4 reports
R
Rosie Cortimiglia
Gretna, Louisiana โ€ข March 1919
M
Mary Romano
New Orleans, Louisiana โ€ข May 1918
P
Pauline Bruno
New Orleans, Louisiana โ€ข May 1918
I
Iorlando Jordano
Gretna, Louisiana โ€ข March 1919

Investigation Verdict

Uncertain

The Axeman case represents a genuine historical mystery with documented police records and newspaper coverage. While the attacks definitely occurred, the killer's identity remains unknown. The jazz letter adds an element that seems almost too theatrical, leading some to question its authenticity. However, multiple survivors provided consistent descriptions of a tall, dark figure. The sudden cessation of attacks suggests either the killer died, moved away, or was satisfied with the terror achieved. Without DNA evidence or modern forensic techniques available in 1918-1919, this case will likely remain forever unsolved.

// FREE ON iOS //

Get the Full The Axeman of New Orleans File

View all 4 evidence items in full resolution. Read 4 eyewitness reports. Interactive maps, audio player, and 500+ more case files โ€” free on iOS.

4 Evidence Items4 Eyewitness ReportsInteractive MapsWeekly New Cases
4.8 stars ยท Free ยท No subscription required